Difference Between Radial And Axial Flow Pump

In the world of fluid dynamics and pump technology, two primary types of centrifugal pumps stand out: radial flow pumps and axial flow pumps. These pumps are essential in various industries, from water treatment and agriculture to power generation and chemical processing. While both types serve the purpose of moving fluids, they differ significantly in their design, operation, and applications.

Working Principle

The fundamental distinction between radial and axial flow pumps lies in their working principles, which dictate how they impart energy to the fluid being pumped.

Radial flow pumps, also known as centrifugal pumps, operate on the principle of centrifugal force. As the impeller rotates, it imparts kinetic energy to the fluid, causing it to move radially outward from the center of the impeller. This radial movement creates a low-pressure area at the impeller's eye, drawing more fluid into the pump. The fluid gains both velocity and pressure as it moves through the impeller and into the pump casing.

In contrast, axial flow pumps work on the principle of lift, similar to how an aircraft wing generates lift. The impeller blades in an axial flow pump are designed to create a pressure difference between their upper and lower surfaces as they rotate. This pressure difference propels the fluid along the axis of the pump, parallel to the shaft. The fluid's movement is primarily in the axial direction, with minimal radial component.

The different working principles of these pumps make them suitable for varying applications. Radial flow pumps are often used in situations requiring high pressure and moderate flow rates, while axial flow pumps excel in applications demanding high flow rates at lower pressures.

Impeller Design

The impeller is the heart of any centrifugal pump, and its design plays a crucial role in determining the pump's performance characteristics. The impeller designs of radial and axial flow pumps differ significantly to accommodate their respective working principles.

Radial flow pumps typically feature closed impellers with curved vanes. These impellers have a disc-like shape with vanes extending from the center to the outer edge. The vanes are usually enclosed between two discs - the hub (or front shroud) and the back shroud. This enclosed design helps to increase efficiency by reducing fluid recirculation. As the impeller rotates, the fluid enters at the center and is flung outward between the vanes, gaining both velocity and pressure.

Axial flow pump impellers, on the other hand, resemble propellers or fan blades. They consist of several spiral blades mounted on a central hub, without shrouds. The blades are designed with a specific pitch and curvature to efficiently move fluid along the pump's axis. As the impeller rotates, the blades push the fluid axially through the pump, similar to how a ship's propeller moves water.

The difference in impeller design reflects the pumps' distinct approaches to energy transfer. Radial flow pump impellers focus on imparting centrifugal force to the fluid, while axial flow pump impellers are optimized for creating axial thrust.

Flow Direction

The flow direction within the pump is another key differentiator between radial and axial flow pumps, influencing their overall design and performance characteristics.

In a radial flow pump, the fluid enters the impeller near its center, typically parallel to the shaft axis. As the impeller rotates, centrifugal force drives the fluid radially outward between the impeller vanes. Upon exiting the impeller, the fluid's direction changes abruptly, turning 90 degrees to flow along the pump casing towards the discharge nozzle. This change in direction is facilitated by the volute or diffuser section of the pump casing, which also helps to convert some of the fluid's velocity into pressure.

Axial flow pumps maintain a consistent flow direction throughout the pumping process. The fluid enters the pump parallel to the shaft axis and continues to flow in this direction as it passes through the impeller. The rotating impeller blades impart energy to the fluid, propelling it axially through the pump casing. There is minimal change in the fluid's radial position as it moves through the pump. The pump casing is typically cylindrical, designed to guide the fluid smoothly from the inlet to the outlet while maintaining its axial flow.

The different flow patterns in these pumps make them suitable for different applications. The radial flow pattern in centrifugal pumps is well-suited for applications requiring significant pressure increase, while the straight-through flow in axial pumps is ideal for moving large volumes of fluid with minimal head increase.

Head and Flow Characteristics

The performance characteristics of radial and axial flow pumps differ significantly, particularly in terms of the head (pressure) they can generate and the flow rates they can handle.

Radial flow pumps generally excel at producing high head pressures but are limited in terms of flow rate. The centrifugal action of these pumps allows them to generate substantial pressure differences between the inlet and outlet. As the fluid moves radially outward through the impeller, it gains both velocity and pressure. The subsequent change in flow direction in the volute or diffuser further contributes to pressure increase. This makes radial flow pumps ideal for applications requiring high pressure, such as high-rise building water supply systems or industrial processes involving viscous fluids.

Axial flow pumps, conversely, are designed to handle high flow rates but typically produce lower head pressures compared to radial flow pumps. The straight-through flow design of axial pumps allows them to move large volumes of fluid efficiently, but the pressure increase is relatively modest. The energy imparted to the fluid is primarily in the form of velocity rather than pressure. Axial flow pumps are well-suited for applications requiring the movement of large volumes of fluid against low to moderate heads, such as irrigation systems, flood control pumps, or cooling water circulation in power plants.

It's worth noting that mixed flow pumps, which combine characteristics of both radial and axial designs, offer a middle ground in terms of head and flow characteristics. These pumps can handle higher flow rates than typical radial flow pumps while generating more head than pure axial flow designs.

Axial Flow Pump Manufacturers

When selecting an axial flow pump manufacturer, it's crucial to choose a company with a proven track record of quality and innovation. One such manufacturer is Tianjin Kairun, a company that has built its reputation on the principles of "scientific and technological innovation, customer first, and the pursuit of excellence."

Tianjin Kairun's commitment to continuous development and customer satisfaction makes them a noteworthy option for those in the market for pumps. Their products are designed to meet the diverse needs of various industries, offering solutions that balance efficiency, reliability, and performance.

For those considering Tianjin Kairun as their axial flow pump manufacturer, the company welcomes inquiries at :catherine@kairunpump.com. This direct line of communication allows potential customers to discuss their specific needs and explore how Tianjin Kairun's products might fit their applications.

References:

1. Gülich, J.F. Centrifugal Pumps. Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

2. Karassik, I.J., Messina, J.P., Cooper, P., & Heald, C.C. Pump Handbook. McGraw-Hill Education.

3. Tuzson, J. Centrifugal Pump Design. John Wiley & Sons.

4. Lobanoff, V.S., & Ross, R.R. Centrifugal Pumps: Design and Application. Elsevier.

5. Nelik, L., & Brennan, J. Progressing Cavity Pumps, Downhole Pumps and Mudmotors. Gulf Publishing Company.

6. Girdhar, P., & Moniz, O. Practical Centrifugal Pumps. Elsevier.